Discover the story of the song > Choctaw County Affair – Carrie Underwood

The song is about a love triangle between the protagonist, her partner Bobby Shaver, and a woman named Cassie O'Grady who disappeared. Cassie was not as sweet as everyone thought and was trying to blackmail the protagonist. The two were accused of Cassie's murder but were acquitted by the jury, who saw it as a small-town affair and not a big deal.