Discover the story of the song > I Held Her In My Arms – Alkaline Trio

The protagonist is reflecting on a past relationship where he held someone in his arms, but it didn't feel like the person he was supposed to be with. He acknowledges that he has been hurt before and is learning things he should have already known. He questions whether they were lovers or if he just wanted to be. The protagonist also expresses a desire to understand what it means to be a boy and a man. He realizes that he needs to let go of the past and not let it destroy the one thing he loves. The overall message of the lyrics seems to be about self-reflection, learning from past mistakes, and finding clarity in relationships.